Making a good custard starts with understanding the science of how a few simple ingredients like eggs, milk and flavourings come together to make the wonderfully velvety texture of a soft-set custard. All custards can essentially be broken down into a simple formula:
If you oversimplify it even further, you’re left with:
Custard Base
Cooking Technique
Custard Base
Flavourings:
Most custards worldwide are flavoured with vanilla. My advice — opt for vanilla extract (not essence) if you want to impress. If you really want to pull out all the stops, go for vanilla bean. Of course, budget matters; make the best choice you can. For Goan caramel custard, the traditional spices of choice are usually nutmeg and cinnamon. If, however, we’re talking about the OG dish, pudim de ovos, then flavourings can include port wine, orange zest and other aromatics. Like many other ingredients in Goan households, the flavourings varied based on social standing and purchasing power. Families who travelled abroad or liaised with European counterparts (not uncommon for certain 15th- and 16th-century Goan families) were — and still are — more likely to use flavourings beyond nutmeg and cinnamon.
Eggs:
When choosing eggs for a rich custard, I prefer brown eggs. Not because they taste different (common misconception — the colour of an eggshell says nothing about taste or quality; it simply reflects the breed of the hen), but because of the rich colour of their yolks. Before custard powder and its artificial yellow hue, the deep sunflower yellow of a good custard came purely from the eggs. That’s why I insist on free-range, antibiotic-free, organic brown eggs. When a dish has fewer ingredients, there’s less to hide behind — so using the best quality makes a world of difference. If brown, organic eggs prove difficult to find, regular eggs will work fine. Small nuances are, in my opinion, generally lost on the average palate. Unless you’re serving chefs and food critics, I doubt anyone will notice.
Question: What’s more important than yolk colour when choosing eggs? Answer: Whether to opt for whole eggs or just yolks as the setting agent.
Chef Zenobia
Using whole eggs leads to a firmer custard that holds its shape but is less wobbly.
Using only yolks yields a softer, silkier texture — my preferred outcome.
You can check out the difference in the outcome by watching the video below
Milk:
While milk seems straightforward, the type of milk you choose can greatly impact texture. First, let’s clarify terms.
SNF (Solids-Not-Fat): Refers to everything in milk except fat and water — proteins, lactose, minerals, vitamins.
Fat %: Pretty self-explanatory; this is how most consumers in India think about milk.
Flan (crème caramel) should be silky and smooth, with just a slight wobble at its center when done
Making perfect caramel custard (a.k.a. crème caramel, flan, leche flan, purin, pudim) requires care. Common issues include a runny texture, failure to set, “eggy” taste, rubberiness, bitter or grainy caramel, and sticking to the mold. Below are beginner-friendly fixes and then “why” explanations. We also highlight key tools and chef tips for all cooking methods (baked, steamed, stovetop custard).
1. Watery or Runny Custard / Not Setting
Cause/Fix: This usually means there’s too much liquid or too few eggs. A classic ratio is about 1 egg per ~125 mL (½ cup) of milk. If too loose, add more egg yolk (or a small amount of cornstarch). Always cook gently in a bain-marie at about 150°C/300°F. Remove the custard when the edges are set but the center still jiggles slightly – it will firm up as it chills. Don’t overmix, as incorporating too much air weakens structure. Chill for several hours or overnight to allow the protein network to stabilize.
Science: Custards set when egg proteins denature and coagulate under gentle heat. Milk alone doesn’t form a strong gel; you need albumin from eggs. Sugar slows protein coagulation, allowing a smoother set. If there are too few eggs, or if the custard is overbaked or rushed, it won’t form a strong network[^1][^2][^3].
2. Custard Tastes Too Eggy
Cause/Fix: A strong eggy flavor can be neutralized by adding vanilla, nutmeg, or cinnamon, and a pinch of salt. Using condensed or evaporated milk instead of plain milk also balances flavors. Overcooked custards develop sulfur notes—remove from the oven when just set.
Science: Egg yolks and whites contain sulfur amino acids that intensify if concentrated or overheated. Sugar and fat dilute this and add roundness, while salt enhances the vanilla profile45.
3. Rubbery or Tough Custard
Cause/Fix: Overcooking or too many eggs can make custard rubbery. Bake at low temperatures (around 150°C) in a water bath. Take it out while still wobbly. To soften texture, use egg yolks instead of whole eggs, and include some cream. Whisk gently to avoid air bubbles, which firm up during baking.
Check out the video below to see the app
Science: Overcooked egg proteins contract and squeeze out water (syneresis), forming a dense matrix. A slow, gentle cook keeps it smooth123.
4. Bitter or Grainy Caramel
Bitter Caramel Fix: Caramel becomes bitter if overcooked. Cook to a deep amber color, then remove from heat immediately.
Grainy Caramel Fix: Crystallization causes graininess. Don’t stir once sugar starts to melt. Instead, swirl the pan gently, and use a wet pastry brush to dissolve sugar crystals on the sides. If needed, strain hot caramel before pouring.
Science: Caramel is polymerized sucrose. If overheated, it breaks into bitter-tasting compounds. Crystals can seed graininess if disturbed during cooking67.
5. Custard Sticks to the Mold
Cause/Fix: Let custard cool fully, then run a thin knife along the edge before unmolding. Refrigerating overnight helps liquefy the caramel, making it easier to release. You can lightly oil molds or swirl caramel in advance.
Science: Caramel hardens as it cools but slowly dissolves into the custard, making unmolding easier the longer it rests6.
6. Air Bubbles or Curdling
Cause/Fix: Avoid aggressive whisking. Always strain the custard before baking and tap ramekins to remove bubbles. Bake in a bain-marie and avoid high heat. If the custard boils or bakes too hot, bubbles expand and rupture the texture.
Science: Bubbles rupture the protein matrix, making the texture coarse or curdled. Gentle handling and stable baking temperatures produce a creamy texture67.
7. Baking, Steaming & Equipment Tips
Always use a water bath with hot water halfway up the ramekins.
Line the pan with a towel to prevent shifting.
Use whole milk or cream for richness.
Use a fine-mesh sieve to strain the custard mixture.
Use a thermometer: caramel reaches amber at ~170°C; custard should bake until the internal temp hits 75–80°C.
For steaming, keep water simmering (not boiling), and cover to avoid water drops on custard.
Use ramekins or metal molds; silicone is trickier but usable if greased.
8. Chef’s Tips
Full-fat dairy makes custard creamier.
Room temperature eggs/milk mix prevents shocking the eggs.
A touch of salt and vanilla enhances flavor.
Different cultures call it crème caramel, flan, purin, leche flan, or caramel pudding—but the science remains universal.
9. Conclusion
Most caramel custard problems come down to ingredient ratios, heat control, and technique. Gentle cooking, straining, and correct ratios guarantee a silky, well-set dessert every time.
Strainer: Always strain the custard mixture into the mould. A fine sieve removes lumps, chalazae and foam, ensuring a velvety smooth result.
Moulds: Use straight-sided ramekins or flan moulds. Metal or glass ramekins are best for even heat; silicone moulds often work but may release differently. If using silicone, lightly grease or dust with sugar first. After baking, invert ramekin onto a plate – the caramel will pool over the custard. (If it sticks, see above.)
Thermometers: A candy thermometer can help if you’re unsure when caramel reaches amber (~170°C/340°F). For baking, an oven thermometer is useful because many ovens run hot. For steaming, you can insert an instant-read probe into the custard; take it out at ~75–80°C (the custard will continue to cook as it cools).
FAQ’S
Q: How long should I chill the custard? A: For best texture, refrigerate at least 4 hours—ideally overnight—so the caramel melds into a sauce and the custard firms perfectly.
Q: Can I use evaporated or condensed milk? A: Yes! Swap up to half the milk for evaporated milk for creaminess, or use some sweetened condensed milk to tame “eggy” notes.
Q: My caramel turned bitter—what went wrong? A: You let the sugar go past deep amber. Heat just until golden amber (~170 °C), then remove immediately—bitter compounds form if you overcook.
Q: Why is my custard rubbery? A: Likely overcooked or too many whole eggs. Lower oven temp to 150 °C, shorten bake time, and use more yolks for a silkier set.
Q: Can I steam instead of bake? A: Absolutely—pre‑boil water, place moulds on a rack, cover tightly, and steam gently so edges cook evenly without condensation dripping in.
Leave a Reply